Surgical Reconstruction of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament: The Central Quadriceps Tendon as an Alternative Graft Source

*Red numbers
indicate references

INTRODUCTION
Significant advances in surgical reconstruction of the anterior
cruciate ligament (ACL) have been made since Jones’ described
open reconstruction with the central one-third patellar tendon
in 1963.29 Advancements in technology, arthroscopic instrumentation,
and surgical skills have decreased surgical morbidity while improving
functional outcome.5,
23
Continued technological
and surgical improvements in the 1990’s eventually enabled surgeons
to perform ACL reconstructions endoscopically. SIZE=”-2″>3, 4, 19, 23, 24, 37

During the evolution of ACL reconstruction surgery, numerous
graft sources have been described. Currently, the most commonly
utilized tissues for ACL reconstruction are autologous semitendinous/gracilis
tendons (ST-G), central one-third patellar tendon (B-PT-B), and
allograft patellar tendon. >13, 14, 21, 22, 31, 32, 46, 49, 50
Each of these grafts has been touted
to reliably restore knee stability, thereby enabling many patients
to return to pre-injury activity levels. Despite these reports,
complications have been noted with all three types of tendons,
the most frequent being anterior knee pain. SIZE=”-2″>1, 6, 7, 9, 10, 12, 17, 18

Based upon its proven efficacy,
the central 1/3 autologous patellar tendon is considered by a
large number of orthopaedic surgeons to be the graft of choice
in the symptomatic ACL-deficient patient. However, the incidence
of anterior knee pain with the use of this graft has been reported
from 13% to 47%, which diminishes the functional outcome in a
large percentage of individuals. SIZE=”-2″>1, 35, 43-45, 51 Moreover, due to technical factors such as tunnel
angle and graft length, many B-PT-B grafts cannot be secured
at the joint level, resulting in non-anatomic graft fixation.
In an effort to eliminate these problems, other graft sources
have been explored. The ideal ACL graft should result in minimal
or no damage to the patient’s tissues after harvest. It should
enable immediate rigid fixation and reproduce the normal anatomy
of the native ACL. It should also restore normal proprioception
and kinematics to the knee. Although numerous graft sources have
been reported, currently, no graft material, autograft or allograft,
can meet all these requirements.

In an effort to minimize post-surgical
anterior knee pain after ACL reconstruction, the use of semitendinosus/gracilis
tendons has been reported. Advocates of ST-G (hamstrings) point
out that post-operative patellar pain is diminished by virtue
of the patellar mechanism not being violated during graft harvest.
Various authors have reported the incidence of anterior pain
to vary from 3% to 21% following hamstrings ACL reconstruction.<FONT
COLOR=”#ff0000″ SIZE=”-2″>2, 11, 15, 26, 30,
33, 42 However, in the
author’s experience, the use of hamstrings for ACL reconstruction
does not eliminate anterior knee pain in many patients. In addition,
some authors have reported increased tibial translation in females
after ST-G ACL reconstruction. >16

Allograft B-PT-B has been advocated
as an alternative graft source due to the lack of harvest morbidity
and decreased operative time required. SIZE=”-2″>25, 32, 36, 41, 46 However, despite the diminished risk of disease
transmission, opponents of allografts cite reports of prolonged
graft-tunnel healing and intraarticular reactions to some allografts.<FONT
COLOR=”#ff0000″ SIZE=”-2″>28, 40

As a result of the continued
controversy regarding the correct ACL graft source, an alternative
graft has emerged, the central quadriceps tendon (CQT). The central
quadriceps tendon was reported as a graft source as early as
1979 by Marshall et al, however, it did not gain popularity among
surgeons until the 1980’s and 1990’s. SIZE=”-2″> 8, 21, 34, 47 Proponents of the CQT cite it’s greater cross-sectional
area, lower strain at failure, and lower modulus of elasticity
when compared to patellar tendon. SIZE=”-2″>48
Advocates have also cited the lower incidence of patellofemoral
symptoms after CQT graft usage. >20, 31
Our experience at the University of South Alabama Medical Center
is similar, with less then 5% of patients demonstrating postoperative
anterior knee pain symptoms after CQT ACL reconstruction.

The CQT consists of a central
portion of the quadriceps tendon approximately 10-11mm wide.
The graft depth extends 7mm with an average length of approximately
80-90mm. When the graft is harvested as the initial portion of
the surgical procedure, the central portion is obtained without
violation of the suprapatellar pouch or transection of the quadriceps
tendon. This eliminates the need to repair the pouch or tendon
before proceeding with the arthroscopic portion of the procedure.

Initial descriptions of the use of the CQT described harvest
of the tendon without a bone block from the patella.31 Prior
to the development of bioabsorable screws for soft tissue fixation,
such a graft would have required the tendon ends had to be secured
by sutures tied over a post, such a staple, button, or screw.
Several biomechanical studies have demonstrated that such fixation
does not reconstitute the normal isometricity of the ACL, with
increased instability noted as the tibial side is fixed further
away from the articular surface. SIZE=”-2″>27, 38
Consequently, many authors now advocate graft fixation near the
articular surface insertions of the native ACL. SIZE=”-2″>39
When the CQT is being contemplated as a graft source, articular
fixation can be accomplished by harvesting a patellar bone block
and fixing both ends of the graft with bioabsorbable screws near
the surface of the tibia and femur.

SURGICAL TECHNIQUE
After previous studies (radiographs, MRI) and clinical examination
confirm that the ACL is disrupted and causing symptomatic instability,
the patient is brought to the operating room for reconstruction.
The CQT is harvested through a short 2-3 inch incision obliquely
along the lines of the quadriceps mechanism. After delineation
of the quadriceps tendon, a 10mm x 7mm x 85mm graft is harvested,
being careful to not violate the suprapatellar pouch. At the
distal end of the quadriceps tendon a 10mm x 25mm x 8mm bone
plug is harvested from the proximal end of the patella. The patellar
defect can be later filled with cancelleous bone from the tibial
reamings or with allograft chips. The CQT is sized on a back
table to fit through the smallest tunnel that the tendon (not
the bone) will glide through easily; the bone plug is trimmed
to fit accordingly. This usually represents 9-10mm. Two #2 Ethibond
sutures are placed in the patellar bone plug, while two #1 Ethibond
sutures are whipped stitched in the tendon end.

After the stitches are in place
and CQT has been sized, appropriate markings are made to aid
the surgeon during arthroscopic reconstruction. In our use of
the CQT, we place the tendon side in the femoral tunnel, with
the patellar bone block in the tibia. First, a pen mark is made
at the bone-tendon junction. Next, a distance of 35mm is measured
from the CQT-bone junction. This marked area represents the approximate
intraarticular distance of the native ACL. This distance is approximately
30mm in most individuals, however, we allocate an additional
5mm in case the graft slides more proximally in the femoral tunnel.
The distance of the remaining tendon represents the portion of
the tendon that will be pulled into the femoral tunnel (~25mm).
The following calculation is what we use in preparing the CQT
graft for implantation:
85mm {total graft} – 60mm {bone plug + intraarticular
tendon} = 25mm {femoral tunnel}
The graft is set in a moist sponge until later implantation.

After harvest of the CQT, a
routine knee arthroscopy is performed. We routinely perform a
5-7mm lateral notchplasty, along with debridement or repair of
any meniscal lesions. Using a standard tibial guide set at an
angle of 55o, we drill a 9mm tibial tunnel centered 5mm anterior
to the PCL within the footprint of the native ACL. After the
posterior portion of the tibial tunnel has been debrided of all
soft tissue and rasped posteriorly, a 7mm offset endoscopic guide
is placed through the tibial tunnel at the “10:30”
or “1:30” positions on the posterior femoral notch.
A 9-10mm femoral tunnel is reamed to the depth of the previous
calculations (~ 25mm).

After reaming, an eyed Beath
pin (Arthrex, Naples, FL) is placed in the femoral tunnel. Sequential
impaction dilatation of the tibial and femoral bone tunnels is
performed to increase the bone density of the tunnels for bioabsorable
screw placement. After the tunnels are dilated to the size of
the graft (9-10mm), the tendon side of the CQT is brought into
the femoral tunnel. Through the anteromedial or an accessory
anterior portal, a bioabsorable screw of the same diameter as
the femoral tunnel is placed anterior to the graft. Fixation
of the graft is assessed by pulling upon the tibial sutures,while
the knee is put through a range of motion. Tensioning the graft
through several motion cycles diminishes creep within the graft
prior to tibial fixation. After the graft is assessed in extension
for signs of impingement, the knee is placed in 10o-20o of flexion
with 5kg of tension place upon the tibial sutures. The graft
is fixed adjacent to the tibial articular surface with a 10mm
bioabsorable interference screw. The knee is assessed for anterior
tibial translation and the wounds closed with absorbable sutures.
Prior to waking the patient, an intraarticular pain pump is placed
within the knee.

CLINICAL EXPERIENCE
At the University of South Alabama Medical Center, our experience
with CQT spans over 2 years, with nearly 20 cases. To date we
are gathering 2 year follow-up data. 1 patient ruptured his graft
during athletics (collegiate athlete) at 9 months postoperatively.
No patient has reported significant patellofemoral pain and there
have been no ruptures of the quadriceps tendon. All patients
have been happy with their results, indicating that they believe
the procedure improved their quality of life.

Other authors have reported
good results with the CQT. Fulkerson reported excellent results
with the use of the CQT with either endobutton or bioabsorbable
screw fixation.20,
31
Leitman et al reported
on 65 CQT graft cases with a KT-1000 side to side differences
of 2.1mm at 1-2 year follow-up. The authors noted that no patient
had patellofemoral pain and all subjects had returned to their
previous level of activity with no instances of quadriceps tendon
rupture.31

CONCLUSIONS
Individuals with a disrupted anterior cruciate ligament and symptomatic
knee instability often require surgical reconstruction of the
ACL. Over the last several decades, tremendous technological
advances have enabled surgeons to reconstruct the ACL with a
more anatomic and durable graft, while minimizing postoperative
morbidity. As the evolution of ACL graft material continues,
numerous graft choices are available. The central quadriceps
tendon (CQT) is an alternative graft source with biomechanical
properties comparable to or better than a bone-patellar tendon-bone
or double-looped hamstrings graft. In early follow-up studies,
patients undergoing CQT ACL reconstruction have demonstrated
minimal patellofemoral symptoms and excellent clinical function.
The CQT provides another weapon in the orthopaedic surgeon’s
repertoire of surgical graft alternatives to reconstruct the
symptomatic ACL-deficient knee.

REFERENCES

    1. Aglietti P, Buzzi R, D’Andria
      S, et al. Patellofemoral problems after intraarticular anterior
      cruciate ligament reconstruction. Clin Orthop 1993;228:195.
    2. Aglietti P, Buzzi R, Zaccherotti
      G, et al. Patella tendon versus doubled semitendinosus and gracilis
      tendons for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Am J Sports
      Med 1994;22:211.
  • Bach B. Technical pitfalls
    Kurosaka interference screw fixation. Am J Knee Surg 1989;2:76-82.
  • Bach B, Tradonsky S, Bojchuk
    J, et al. Arthroscopically assisted anterior cruciate ligament
    reconstruction using patellar tendon autograft. Five to nine-year
    follow-up evaluation. Am J Sports Med 1998;26:20-29.
  • Bach JB. Arthroscopy-assisted
    patellar tendon substitution for anterior cruciate ligament insufficiency:
    Surgical technique. Am J Knee Surg 1989;2:3-20.
  • Bear B, Cohen S, Bowen M,
    et al. Patellar fracture after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction
    using bone patellar bone autogenous grafts. Orthop Trans 1996;29:9.
  • Berg E. Management of patellar
    fractures associated with central third bone-patellar tendon-bone
    autograft ACL reconstruction. Technical note. Arthroscopy 1996;12:756.
  • Blauth W. Die zweizugelige
    Ersatzplastik des vorderen Kreuzband der Quadricepsshene. Unfallheilkunde
    1984;87:45-51.
  • Bonamo J, Krinick R, Sparn
    A. Rupture of the patellar ligament after use of its central-third
    for anterior cruciate reconstruction. J Bone Joint Surg 1984;66-A:1294.
  • Bonatus T, Alexander A. Patellar
    fracture and avulsion of the patellar ligament complicating arthroscopic
    anterior ligament reconstruction. Orthop Rev 1991;20:770.
  • Brown C, Steiner M, Carson
    E. The use of hamstring tendons for anterior cruciate ligament
    reconstruction. Clin Sports Med 1993;12:723.
  • Christen B, Jakob R. Fractures
    associated with patellar ligament grafts in cruciate ligament
    surgery. J Bone Joint Surg 1992;74-B:617.
  • Clancy W, Nelson D, Reider
    B, et al. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using one
    third of the patellar tendon augmented by extraarticular tendon
    transfers. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1982;64:352-359.
  • Cooper D, Deng X, Burstein
    A, et al. The strength of the central thord patellar tendon graft.
    A biomechanical study. Am J Sports Med 1993;21:818-824.
  • Corry I, Webb J, Clingeleffer
    A. Endoscopic reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament,
    a comparison of patella tendon with four strand hamstring autograft.
    (poster). In: 10th Combined Orthopaedic Associations Meeting;
    1998; New Zealand; 1998.
  • Corry I, Webb J, Clingeleffer
    A, et al. Arthroscopic reconstruction of the anterior cruciate
    ligament. A comparison of patellar tendon autograft and four-strand
    hamstring tendon autograft. Am J Sports Med 1999;27(3):444-454.
  • Crosby L, Kamins P. Fracture
    of the patella during graft harvest for cruciate ligament reconstruction.
    Complications in Orthopaedics 1991;6:104.
  • DeLee J, Craviotto D. Rupture
    of the quadriceps tendon after a central-third patellar tendon
    anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Am J Sports Med 1991:415.
  • Ferrari J, Bush-Joseph C,
    Bach B. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using bone-patellar
    tendon-bone grafts: autograft and allograft endoscopic techniques
    and two-incision autograft technique. Op Tech in Spts Med 1999;7(4):156-171.
  • Fulkerson J. Central quadriceps
    free tendon for anterior curciate ligament reconstruction. Op
    Tech Sports Med 1999;7(4):195-200.
  • Fulkerson J, Langeland R.
    An alternative cruciate reconstruction graft: the central quadriceps
    tendon. Arthroscopy 1995;11:252-254.
  • Hamner D, Brown C, Steiner
    M, et al. Hamstring tendon grafts in ACL reconstruction: Biomechanics
    of mltiple strands and tensioning techniques. J Bone Joint Surg
    Am 1999;81:549-557.
  • Hardin G, Bach B, Bush-Joseph
    C, et al. Endoscopic single incision ACL reconstruction using
    patellar tendon autograft: Surgical technique. Am J Knee Surg
    1992;5:144-155.
  • Harner C, Marks P, Fu F, et
    al. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: Endoscopic versus
    two-incision technique. Arthroscopy 1994;10:502-512.
  • Harner C, Olson E, Irrgang
    J, et al. Allograft versus autograft anterior cruciate ligament
    reconstruction: 3- to 5- year outcome. Clin Orthop 1996;324:134-144.
  • Hormel S, Larson R, Larry
    I. Arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using
    double-loop semitendinosus and gracilis tendons: A three-year
    follow-up study. (paper 508). In: In final program American Academy
    of Orthopaedic Surgeons 62nd Annual Meeting; Florida. p. 316.
  • Ishibashi Y, Rudy T, Livesay
    G, et al. The effect of the anterior cruciate ligament graft
    fixation level, on knee stability: Evaluations using a robotic
    testing system. Arthroscopy 1997;13:177-182.
  • Jackson D, Windler G, Simon
    T. Intraarticular reaction associated with the use of freeze-dried,
    ethylene oxide-sterilized bone-patella tendon-bone allografts
    in the reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament. Am J
    Sports Med 1990;18:1-11.
  • Jones K. Reconstruction of
    the anterior cruciate ligament: A technique using the central
    third of the patellar ligament. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1963;45:925-932.
  • Larson R, Ericksen D. Complications
    in the use of the hamstring tendons for anterior cruciate ligament
    reconstruction. Sports Medicine and Arthroscopy Review 1997;5:83.
  • Leitman E, Morgan C, Grawl
    D. Quadriceps tendon anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction
    using the all-inside technique. Op Tech in Spts Med 1999;7(4):179-188.
  • Levitt R, Malinin T, Posada
    A, et al. Reconstruction of anterior cruciate ligaments with
    bone-patellar tendon-bone and achilles tendon allografts. Clin
    Orthop 1994;303:67-78.
  • Maeda A, Shino K, Horibe S,
    et al. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with multistranded
    autogenous semitendinosus tendon. Am J Sports Med 1996;24:504.
  • Marshall J, Warren R, Wickiewicz
    T, et al. The anterior cruciate ligament. A technique of repair
    and reconstruction. Clin Orthop 1979;143:97-106.
  • Martin R, Galloway M, Diagneault
    J, et al. Patello-femoral pain following ACL reconstruction:
    Bone grafting the patellar defect. Orthop Trans 1996;20:9.
  • Miller M, Harner C. The use
    of allograft. Techniques and results. Clin in Spts Med 1993;12(4):757-770.
  • Miller M, Hinkin D. The “N
    + 7 rule” for tibial tunnel placement in endoscopic anterior
    cruciate ligament reconstruction. Arthroscopy 1996;12:124-126.
  • Morgan C, Kalman C, Grawl
    D. Isometry testing for ACL reconstruction revisited. Arthroscopy
    1995;11:647-659.
    Morgan C, Kalman V, Grawl D. Definitive landmarks for reproducible
    tibial tunnel placement in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.
    Arthroscopy 1995;11:275-288.
  • Nikolaou P, Seaber A, Glisson
    R, et al. Anterior cruciate ligament allograft transplantation:
    long-term function, histology, revascularization, and operative
    technique. Am J Sports Med 1986;14:348-360.
  • Olson E, Harner C, Fu F, et
    al. Clinical use of fresh, frozen soft tissue allografts. Orthopedics
    1992;15(10):1225-1232.
  • O’Neill D. Arthroscopically
    assisted reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament. A
    prospective randomized analysis of three techniques. J Bone Joint
    Surg 1996;78-A:803.
  • Rubinstein R, Shelbourne K.
    Prevention of complications and minimizing morbidity after autogenous
    bone-patella tendon-bone anterior ligament reconstruction. Oper
    Tech Sports Med 1993;1:72.
  • Sachs R, Daniel D, Stone M,
    et al. Patellofemoral problems after anterior cruciate ligament
    reconstruction. Am J Sports Med 1989;17:760.
  • Shelbourne K, Trumper R. Preventing
    anterior knee pain after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.
    Am J Sports Med 1997;25:41.
  • Shino K, Kimura T, Hirose
    H, et al. Reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament by
    allogeneic tendon graft. J Bone Joint Surg 1986;68-B:739-746.
  • Staubli H. Arthroscopically
    assisted ACL reconstruction using autologous quadriceps tendon.
    In: Jakob R, Staubli H, editors. The Knee and the Cruciate Ligaments.
    Berlin: Springer Verlag; 1992. p. 443-451.
  • Staubli H, Birrer S. The popliteus
    tendon and tis fascicles at the popliteal hiatus: Gross anatomy
    and functional arthroscopic evalution with and without anterior
    cruciate ligament deficiency. Arthroscopy 1990;6:209-220.
  • Steiner M, Hecker A, Brown
    A, et al. Anterior cruciate ligament graft fixation: Comparison
    of hamstring and patellar tendon grafts. Am J Sports Med 1994;22:240-247.
  • Steiner M, Kowalk D. Anterior
    cruciate ligament reconstruction using hemstrings for a two-incision
    technique. Op Tech in Spts Med 1999;7(4):172-178.
  • Weiss R, Re L, Rintz K. Incidence
    of anterior knee pain after treatment for anterior cruciate ligament
    rupture. Arthroscopy 1933;9:366.

Address correspondence to:
Albert W. Pearsall, IV, MD
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery
University of South Alabama Medical Center
2451 Fillingim Street
Mobile, Alabama 36617
Email: apearsal@usamail.usouthal.edu

2020-06-02T16:16:34-05:00February 13th, 2008|Contemporary Sports Issues, Sports Exercise Science, Sports Management, Sports Studies and Sports Psychology|Comments Off on Surgical Reconstruction of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament: The Central Quadriceps Tendon as an Alternative Graft Source

Sports Equipment and Technology

Introduction

In this Olympic year it is appropriate to consider the roles that sport play in our societies. While the natural focus of attention associated with an Olympiad is on “the elite” of sport, we as administrators in the profession cannot lose sight of the fact that sport is truly an activity for everyone in society. Thus it is also appropriate that the focus of this conference is on sport and social inclusion which is really what SPORT FOR ALL should be all about.

I have been asked to address the topic of the application of technology to sports equipment. This is difficult to do in 30 minutes but I will attempt to provide an overview of how technology is changing the nature of sport. The discussion of the application of technology in the world of sport can be done in two broad areas:

1st Sport specific applications of technology most notably in the area of equipment.
2nd How today’s “technological revolution” can be applied to sport. This will be addressed in terms of how technology can impact broad based participation and promote social inclusion.

When looking at how technology can enhance social inclusion and to expand the base of participation in sport throughout society, it is the second case that is most significant. First, however, I will provide an overview of technology in sport specific applications.

Sport Specific Applications

First of all, when we say technology, what exactly do we mean? There are several definitions from the dictionary, but I picked only two to illustrate the scope and impact of technology on the human race. These are:

1st The application of science or a technical method of achieving an intended purpose.
An even broader definition is:
2nd Technology is the totality of the means employed to provide the objects necessary for human sustenance and comfort.

As you can see, there is a lot of latitude when we start talking about how technology affects sport or even more narrowly, sports equipment.

There was a time when technology and equipment had very little impact on sport, even in the Olympics. As you may recall, the athletes who participated in ancient Olympic Games did so in the nude using implements such as discii that were both “off the rack” and shared among the competitors. So it is safe to say in this instance, there was no real advantage that accrued to any participant as a result of the application of “technology” in-so-far as equipment or personal gear was concerned.

But it is equally safe to say that in the Olympics of the modern era, technology applied to sport has played an important role both in training and in competition. This has manifested itself in a variety of ways that range from the creation of new sports, to facilities used to accommodate them, to the equipment used by the athletes in competition to the training support used by teams to prepare the athletes for competition. Moreover, the processes employed in the adoption of technology and technological methods to enhance sport and recreation have accelerated with each successive Olympiad. These advances in technology, as with all other walks of life, have had a marked impact in most aspects of sports. Examples of this impact include:

1st The development of new sports both recreational and competitive.

These changes reflect a natural evolution in sports as well as generational shifts that are more pronounced. In the latter instance, there are new multi-sport competitions such as the “X-Games,” which include events such as mountain biking, in-line roller skating, roller boarding, boogie boarding and snow boarding. The X-Games are, incidently, named after the 15 to 30 year old demographic group called “Generation X” who make up the largest participant group for these sports which have sprung up to compete for sponsorship and media space with older, more established events.

A very good example of this process is the introduction of snow boarding in the Nagano Olympiad. At one time, snow boarding was banned from most ski resorts because of a perceived conflict on the part of resort managers between the snow board enthusiasts and the more traditional skier. This antipathy stemmed from both the free-wheeling way in which the snow boards are used on the slopes and a perceived cultural clash between the two sets of resort patrons. Now most ski resorts could not survive or remain economically viable without the revenue generated by snow boarders.

2nd Which brings us to facility design. The application of technology in sport facility design has yielded real changes in terms of athlete use, spectator comfort and usable life span. Example of these changes include:

Equipment which makes competition judging and compiling results more accurate. Further, technological applications such as photo-finish timing devices tied in with communications technology for in-stadium displays such as scoreboards and broadcasting make the events more enjoyable for the spectators.

Technological changes have resulted in facilities that are more cost efficient to operate resulting in the freeing up of scarce financial resources for programs which would have otherwise been expended for operating costs such as utilities. Among these advances are lighting options that extends the useable hours of facility operation or computerized HVAC controls that gain operating efficiency as well as increasing both athlete and spectator comfort.

And lastly, technological change frequently results in better building finishes that extend the life of the facility, are safer for the participants and are less costly to maintain. Most notable in this area are finishes such as sports flooring and playing surfaces.

There exists, however, a real irony with respect to the application of technology in sport facility design, at least in North America. While on the one hand technological advances allow for a greater life span of the facility through the development of components such as better finishes and surfaces, on the other hand technological changes also drive obsolescence causing facilities to be replaced for economic reasons long before they are worn out. Thus stadia and auditoriums which should last more than 50 years are now being razed and replaced at great cost after only 30 years of service in many cities.

3rd Technology has affected equipment design at all levels; from low level recreational activities to high level competitive sports. We’ve already seen that the application of technology to sports serves a role in creating whole new sports events. The use of technological tools such as Computer Assisted Design (CAD) can also play a role in the enhancement of sport equipment. A good example of this and well known in sailing circles is the story of how America³ won the 1992 Americas Cup, which is probably the most venerable race in among the oldest of sports. Through the application of technology (and a large amount of money) a rookie skipper surprised the veterans and took the prize.

A better example of applied technology in sports is the use of “smart” equipment that incorporates sensors and computers as a part of their function. Most international caliber athletes typically undergo some form of human performance evaluation as a part of their training regimen. This can range from exercise stress testing and cardiovascular assessment to the use of very sophisticated biomechanical analysis using equipment such as the APAS system. Computer technology can even be found in equipment used for the evaluation of strength and conditioning.

4th Equipment construction also benefits from the application of composite materials which reduces weight while yielding increased strength and extended life spans. Composite materials can certainly be found in high level competitive equipment such as bikes, skis, racquets, and other types of gear such kayaks which almost by definition are targeted toward the elite competitor.

But it is also important to note that advances in materials have made sport participation safer and has penetrated down the sports hierarchy to the recreational user, for example, in items such as bike helmets.

5th And lastly, technology is also applied to personal sports gear such as clothing and shoes. A recent, albeit controversial example, is the full body suits used in swimming which streamline the competitor reducing times in a sport where winning or losing is measured in hundredths of a second.

Unfortunately, the use of technology in enhancing sports facilities and equipment is generally an expensive proposition. And because of the expense involved in these applications, the benefits derived at least initially tend to be limited to the upper end of the sports hierarchy. For example, because of cost, changes brought about in sport through the application of technology tend to be available first to elite level athletes and teams. By definition, elite level athletes and sports are exclusive and thus omit the broader base of participants further down the sports hierarchy.

Nonetheless, there is a “trickle down” effect. As more people seek out the “best and newest”, market economies come into play and the cost for equipment brought about or improved through technological innovation declines as distribution is expanded. Unfortunately, this trickle down effect is frequently a process that is measured in years. In the meantime, technological development as applied to sports equipment continues with the next generation of the “newest and the best” being developed. And as before, this new generation of equipment is out of the reach of many sports participants. And so the cycle continues.

This division between the “haves” and the “have nots” is a problem for the profession and it manifests itself in many ways. Consider the following example.

In the United States those professional teams that can afford better facilities and equipment, frequently developed through the application of technology, typically earn more revenue. With a better revenue stream, the team owners can obtain better performers. Better performers yield better team results, which creates more interest by the fans. Increased interest on the part of the fans means an increase in ticket sales and more revenue generated for the team. More revenue means better facilities and players and so too does this cycle continue.

Striking a competitive balance is a real challenge facing the professional leagues in North America. But North America is not alone with this problem. Relative cost related to the application of technology is also a challenge with respect to international sports as well. Wealthier nations, such as those found in Western Europe or the United States, can better afford the training facilities, expensive composite equipment and personal gear required for elite level competition. Thus the benefits of technological advances applied to sports accrue most greatly to those who can afford the price.

The point is that the application of technology to sports equipment is by no means universal and is, at best, unevenly applied. And solving this problem is very difficult because of the inherent conflicts of interests between the various stake-holders or constituencies in sports. Among the stake holders are the fans who are the consumers of the sport product. The people who pay to see sport competitions, whether it be the individual fan or media companies, want the excitement of high scoring contests or record setting performances. Athletes and participants want the recognition that accompanies victory and the setting of records. Regulators such as the national and international sport governing bodies similarly are motivated to gain the best possible competitive advantage for their teams and athletes. Equipment manufacturers want to recoup their investment in research and product development.

Thus, at least at the upper end of the sports hierarchy, there is a natural pressure among all of these constituencies toward the ever more efficient and costly facilities and equipment. This process continues to increase the gap between those who can afford to acquire the “latest and the best” and those who cannot. It is very important, however, this natural tendency toward a division between the “haves” and “have nots” be controlled in the best interests of the sports profession.

This is simply because central to the philosophy of sport is the concept that on any given day, every athlete participating in a competition has a chance to emerge victorious. It is this idea of competitiveness that keeps fans returning to the stadium and buying tickets, the revenue from which supports the athletes and the teams. Should the fans believe that too great an advantage has accrued to one competitor or another, their interest will diminished to the detriment of all. This is why drug abuse by athletes brings such severe penalties from sports regulators and why fans tend to lose interest in a given sport when the “best team that money can buy” consistently wins the championship.

The challenge then for sports administrators is to insure that too great an advantage does not accrue too greatly to one team or another through the application of technology for better equipment or facilities. Those who are in a position to develop rules with respect to the use of sports equipment or to fund equipment or facility acquisitions for economically disadvantaged teams through the administration of grants need to bear in mind the fundamental principle of parity in competition.

So the question arises, what technology is available and can be applied toward leveling the playing field for all? What equipment can promote social inclusion with respect to sport? Interestingly enough, the answer to that question lies within what most people think of in terms of “technology” itself.

The Technological Revolution

We are living in the midst of one of those very unusual occurrences that come along every few generations. What has been occurring over the past few decades is a fundamental paradigm shift that is moving society as a whole from the age of industry to the age of information. The currency in this new society that is being formed is called IT – information technology. IT is simply the tools and methods used for the identification, organization and manipulation of facts that we call data. IT has become the engine that is driving all sectors of today’s economy be it industry, government, education or indeed, sports.

The most important piece of equipment that lies at the heart of the whole IT process is the computer. The computer and the software that it runs is an essential element in the new societal paradigm and it is a key to success for the modern sports administrator. It is THE piece of equipment that allows the sports administrator to maximize the return on scarce resources whether this is people, facilities and equipment or finances. In turn, it is also perhaps the single most important tool to insure the extended reach of sport and recreational programming and with it, the whole idea of inclusion in these activities of the greatest number of participants.

Just as money has been the currency and a source of power in the old paradigm, information is the currency and a source of power in the new paradigm. No where is the old saying “that knowledge is power” more true than in a society where information or data is what drives the economy. The secret to managing knowledge and information is in the development and maintenance of databases.

A data base is nothing more than an organized collection of common records that can be searched, accessed and modified. Database software is very widespread as most standard office computer software packages will typically have a simple database program in addition to word processing, spreadsheet and presentation applications.

There is, however, a far more powerful and useful kind of database for sport managers than the one that comes in the standard software suite. This most powerful of data management tools is called a relational database. Very simply, a relational database is a data management system that stores information in a series of tables e.g. rows and columns of data. When the operator conducts a search, a relational database allows the individual to match data from one table with data from a second to produce a third table or a report. So for example, if you are a manager conducting a complex sports competition, the details of which have been entered into a relational database, the event manager can retrieve the time for a scheduled event from one table, a roster that has the names of qualified referees who can officiate the event from another table, their availability from a third table and produce a report that lists all of the personnel who can undertake the officiating task. The same type of event management software can assist the sports manager with a myriad of other tasks ranging from facility scheduling, equipment set up and knock-down, or even ordering soft drinks for the concession stand.

If one of the goals of the sports manager is social inclusion, and I submit to you that it should be, then the computer and the data base software that it contains within it are one of the key tools available to them to help them to reach this goal. That this is the case can be seen by the kinds of sport program information that can be contained within these databases aside from the event management sample just cited:

  1. Athlete or team rosters to include demographic information such as name, sex, age, contact information such as addresses and phone numbers and so on. Other parts of the database can contain details on medical conditions, performance history, or other participation characteristics of the athletes.
  2. There are databases that can assist coaches organize scouting reports of the opposition as well as conditioning and preparation activities for their own athletes.
  3. Rosters of volunteers such as officials, drivers, timekeepers, or medical staff. Aside from the similar demographic details, a database of this type might also contain information about availability and reliability, e.g. do they actually show up when they volunteer?
  4. Donors or potential donors whether this be for money or in-kind services. Here too will be demographic information but also other kinds of details as to the source of their motivation or affiliation, frequency of participation and so on.
  5. While the foregoing are examples of useful data with respect to programming, databases are also essential for administrative information. Examples here include equipment and inventory lists, facility maintenance software packages, marketing information such as ticket sales, accounting and business records, employee directories and the list could go on and on.

Once entered, data can be easily manipulated. More importantly, databases can and should be updated to record changes. Bear in mind that the passage of time presents a more comprehensive picture of most activities and the ability of record change and make sense of them is essential for long term survival. Further, there is nothing so constant as change and a well thought out and maintained data base is a great way to record those changes and their implications to the organization.

There are a couple of keys to remember when considering the acquisition of this kind of software:

1st System capacity which addresses the hardware questions. Bear in mind that a relational data base can consume huge amounts of memory capacity.
2nd The degree of accuracy required with the application is an issue. Standard vendor prepared packages typically operate on the basis of the lowest common denominator which usually means that only about 80% of most organization’s needs are met with an off-the-shelf product. So the sport administrator is left with the choice of adapting organizational operating procedures to the software to some degree or writing their own programs. The latter can be hugely time consuming and very expensive. Generally, the more specific modification required for a software product, the more expensive the product becomes and the more difficult it will be to accommodate software upgrades from the vendor.
3rd Lastly, one needs to consider user capabilities. The adoption of information technology and procedures usually means extensive training of the staff.

As great as databases are for effective sport program management, the real power of technology comes when we tie the individual machines together through the medium of a network. This is truly a case where there are synergies created; where the sum is greater the individual parts e.g. 2 + 2 = 6. A computer network simply is the hardware required to connect two or more machines together in such a manner as to allow the sharing of data and other resources.

When I speak of resources, for example, a network can have any number of computers sharing a very good quality printer instead of a using a bunch of stand alone mediocre printers. Proper presentation of the organization’s message is very important for effective marketing and image. Another example of a shared resource is that the network can be driven by a powerful server which can substantially increase computing speed and effectiveness throughout an organization. Most importantly, particularly where relational databases are employed, a network allows the users to share information which is typically stored on a server.

Most larger enterprises, either commercial or sports, use computer networks to link together their operatives. All of the permeations and configurations available to the sports administrator are clearly beyond the scope of this presentation except to note that the most common configuration of these kinds of networks are of the client -server variety. This type of network is where a main server houses most of the information and data base files and the individual operatives access the server through their desktop terminals or workstations which are called clients.

It is important to note that computer networks need not be limited to a single site or facility. Wide Area Networks (WANs) can link together sports administrators located throughout a country. For example, all of the local offices of a national sports body such as the Football Association can be linked whether they be located in Recife or Rio, Brasilia or Belem. All of the administrators so linked can share rosters, performance data, programming information and communicate with each other cheaply and efficiently through the medium of e-mail.

The computer network most familiar to the public is the internet. And the most familiar part of the internet to most people is the World – Wide – Web also known simply as “the Web”.

While the internet has been around for decades going all the way back to ARPAnet in the 1960s, the Web is a comparatively new innovation first introduced in the mid 1990s. It is a medium which presents information in text, audio and graphics, with the latter being both still or animated, in a simple hyper-text computer language readable by a browser. This medium has simply exploded and today there are more than 3.6 million web addresses called Uniform Resource Locators (URLs), many with hundreds of individual pages on their sites. Additional applications for thousands of URLs are received virtually every week. Of these millions of Websites, more than 50% of them are located in the United States but this will eventually change with time. I should note that while much of the data used in this presentation originates from the U.S. Much of what I say is applicable to other nations to a greater or lesser degree already and if not now, then it will certainly be applicable to them at some point in the future. The changes being wrought in society by IT or its brother CT – communications technology – are not confined to any one country and will eventually effect us all.

All the ways in which the Web has changed society are almost too numerous to mention. Suffice to say it has become an extremely important medium of communication and its importance will only continue to grow in the future. For example, USA Today which is the closest thing a national newspaper in America, gets more than three million visits per day. Some 60% of these visits are to its sports pages. Further, there are virtually no professional sports teams in the United States that do not have a Website and most are linked together through networks of Websites coordinated through the various league offices. Just how tight are these linkages is driven in part by agreements between the league teams on activities such as revenue sharing for media broadcasting and merchandise sales among others.

The Web is currently used by professional sports teams in ways that the developers of this technology never envisioned. For example, there are no English language radio broadcasts in Montreal for the Montreal Expos professional baseball team. Fans wanting hear the play-by-play in English can only do so by calling up the team’s Website and listen to it coming across as an audio feed. Another example of how deeply the internet has penetrated professional sports is how some pro hockey teams now require their players to have e-mail addresses as a means to interact with both the team administration and their fans.

These examples lie at the heart of how the internet will affect sports in the future: through the changing of the way that the sports fan will consume the product. Where once sport marketing did not extend much beyond putting out a sign saying “Game Today”, now sports teams must have well developed and extensive Websites to market effectively to their consumers. The trend in this regard is also clear. What will emerge is networks of teams and users bound together by a common interest and driven in part by advances in communications technology.

A good example of this is trend is that of Worldsport.com. This internet presence has succeeded in tying together all 88 members of the General Association of International Sport Federations which represent all of the sports played in the Olympics. Worldsport.com not only hosts the federations individual Webpages, but also provides general technological support through activities such as promotional information and marketing, administrative information for athletes and administrators in secure areas of their sites, educational programming such as certification, logistical support such as a global e – mail communication system and the list could go on and on.

These developments are not limited to the upper end of the sports hierarchy. Compared to the extremely high cost of traditional television broadcast, the comparatively low cost of this technology will bring to sports fans events that could never before be seen broadcast on traditional media. A simple example of how this can occur is an annual sailboat race across the Gulf of Mexico from Mobile to Tampico. Last summer the skipper of a local boat participating in the event took photos with a digital camera of the race activities and the participants every four hours and uplinked them by a satellite phone to his own Website. Thus friends in the community, or anyone else in the world who stumbled into the Web address, could participate in this event as they never could before. Sports events of a distinctly local flavor without the mass appeal that make them economical for television broadcast can so be distributed to anyone with an interest. The Web is not constrained by the limited availability of broadcast channels and high production costs. And while bandwidth is currently an issue for the web, this will resolve itself in the near future with the introduction of broadband technologies.

I’d like to start bringing this discussion to a close with the topic on which we started: sports equipment. I think it appropriate to discuss how the Web will change the sale and distribution of sporting goods. We have already noted that the relative cost for sports equipment can be an issue for the profession, particularly in terms of inclusion by a great number of participants. E-commerce through the internet can play a key role in containing costs for sports equipment as illustrated by the following example.

In the traditional model of manufacture and distribution through a sporting goods store, a tennis racquet which cost $40 to manufacture could be marked up as much as 134% to $94 as it moves through various wholesalers and retailers in the distribution chain to a tennis player. With an e-commerce arrangement whereby the manufacturer can reach the player directly, the mark-up in distribution can be reduced to as little as 20% resulting in a sale price to the end user of $48. The more middle men in a distribution chain, the greater the benefit derived to the end user from using e-commerce distribution. Japan is a classic case in the application of this scenario. Japanese consumers have historically suffered extremely high prices for most consumer products because of a distribution system that has had many layers of middle men in the distribution channel. In Japan today this is changing such that even individual farmers are going on-line with their own websites to sell their produce directly to the consumer, an activity that is empowering both the farmer and the consumer.

E-commerce is well on its way to becoming a force in the world economy as it serves to remove barriers both natural and artificial. The barriers that will vanish include those of time and space as well as national borders both physical and ideological. That this will occur is underscored by the fact that this year e-commerce will employ more than 2 million people and create a turnover in excess of $500 billion. By next year, the turn over is expected to pass $1 trillion.

While this is all well and good, in closing I would like to note a problem similar to that mentioned earlier with respect to the application of technology to sports equipment. Very simply, technological tools are expensive which has resulted in what we call in the United States the Digital Divide. In the U.S., 56% of American adults, 106 million users representing 47% of American households, are connected to the internet and are on-line. These users are largely from the upper and middle class and have the financial wherewithal to purchase computers and internet services. It is a matter of great concern that the very people who stand to benefit the most from economies to be realized through communications technology as outlined earlier in my discussion on e-commerce are the ones least able to afford it. It is the economically disadvantaged that are currently being left out of the IT revolution.

This Digital Divide also transcends national borders. While 56% of American adults are connected to the internet, only 4% of the global population can make that claim. Some areas, Africa for example, are totally disconnected and can only be considered disadvantaged as a result. Herein lies the challenge for the future.

In conclusion, the application of IT to sports management has dramatically changed the way that we do business. Thinking through how we can use this kind of equipment and these tools greatly enhances outcomes. The bottom line is that these IT tools are rapidly becoming a necessity for the sports administrator at whatever level in the sports heirarchy they are working. They are a powerful force for social inclusion in sport and recreational activity and for the profession as a whole.

Thank you.

 


Paper Presented at the
International Seminar for Sport and Social Inclusion
Sao Paulo, Brasil
26-29 June 2000

 

Sponsored by
SESCO
and
COB Brasil, UNESCO, F.I.S.p.T, FICTS, Sport For All and
University of Sao Paulo – School of Physical Education and Sport


 

Address correspondence to:
Dr. T.J. Rosandich, VP of Development
United States Sports Academy
One Academy Drive
Daphne, AL 36526
(334) 626-3303
Email: tjrosand@ussa-sport.ussa.edu

2013-11-27T16:30:16-06:00February 13th, 2008|Contemporary Sports Issues, Sports Exercise Science, Sports Facilities, Sports Management|Comments Off on Sports Equipment and Technology

IOC Culture and Olympic Education Forum : Culture straight from the Internet

As the title suggests, my intention is to present “Culture live on Internet” – a challenge in itself. There can be no question of confining it to a traditional, concept-based discussion, albeit with the aid of slides. A new approach is required, which can be outlined as follows:

  1. This paper (or rather the text, its written expression) will form not the ideas involved as a whole, but the main thread of the experience we are about to share;
  2. This means that the screen (or pages of this publication) is no longer simply a place intended for illustration and documentation; it offers sites that we will open and consult together in real time;
  3. The innovation involves breaking with the limits of a traditional debate and opening it up, outside those limits, to the whole network;
  4. Finally, it is essential to bear in mind that internet is evolving continually, at a speed hitherto unknown, and that the outcome – cyberculture – is being transformed almost as we speak;
  5. Which means we need to be prepared to break with our mental habits and open up to those required by the experience of the “Net”.

 

2017-08-07T15:35:21-05:00February 13th, 2008|Contemporary Sports Issues, Sports History|Comments Off on IOC Culture and Olympic Education Forum : Culture straight from the Internet

IOC Culture and Olympic Education Forum : Prejudice – the link that affects both the world of culture and the world of sports,

Let’s be frank, and not fear words:

  • cultured people/intellectuals, are normally classed as “boring” or, at best, “utopian”;
  • sports people, devoted to the development of excellence in physical performance, supposedly do not make much use of reason or thought processes.

The power of the media and the world’s leaders have long since categorized culture and sport – they are pure divertimento!

The media succeeds in efforts to devote each of these two worlds a specific area, a “ghetto” for a privileged few.

The world’s leaders, in their own way, do the same thing, with the exception of electoral campaigns, where the brilliance of sports heroes and those of art and literature should shine over their own images, which compels them to be seen frequenting these heroes!!

Should we go back, therefore, to the Ancient Greeks? The only ones in Western culture to understand that in man’s flight towards perfection, his best scores were thanks to the efforts of thinkers, artists and Olympic athletes?

Can the current modern market of the “polis” really ignore the “humus” of culture and sport?

Be on your guard, for the divertimento of sport and culture will become the water and oil of the future. The “content” industries will, tomorrow, be those which will overturn the earth and move the world and humanity forward. To ensure your own survival, it would be best to forget about the reactions of the market, and follow instead the feelings of the creative artists, athletes, scientists and philosophers!

2017-08-07T15:35:32-05:00February 13th, 2008|Contemporary Sports Issues, Sports Studies and Sports Psychology|Comments Off on IOC Culture and Olympic Education Forum : Prejudice – the link that affects both the world of culture and the world of sports,

Results and Recommendations of the World Summit on Physical Education

Introduction

 

Over 250 delegates from 80 countries, representing governments, inter-governmental and non-governmental organizations (NGO), and academic institutions attended the World Summit on Physical Education (Berlin, November 3-5, 1999). It was held under the international patronage of the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) and the International Olympic Committee (IOC), and with the co-sponsorship of the World Health Organization (WHO).

On behalf of the participants of the Summit and the International Council of Sport Science and Physical Education (ICSSPE), I present this paper to the Ministers and Senior Officials of Ministries responsible for Education and Sport for discussion at the MINEPS III meeting. The paper combines the latest research, content from keynote presentations and workgroup discussions from the World Summit.

The activities of ICSSPE reflect the interests of a diverse range of multi disciplinary and international member organizations. To date, two-hundred governmental and non-governmental bodies with international, regional, national or local membership form the Council’s world-wide network. ICSSPE is a non-governmental organization in Formal Associate Relations with UNESCO.

The International Committee of Sport Pedagogy (ICSP) within ICSSPE links five international organizations with a common interest in physical education. This Committee is composed of: the Association Internationale des Ecoles Superieures d’Education Physique (AIESEP), the Federation Internationale d’Education Physique (FJ EP), the International Association of Physical Education and Sport for Girls and Women (IAPESGW), the International Federation of Adapted Physical Activity (IFAPA), and the International Society for Comparative Physical Education and Sport (ISGPES). The International Committee of Sports Pedagogy played a leading role in the development of this World Summit on Physical Education. The intention behind these plans has been to:

  • Raise awareness of the positive benefits of Physical Education;
  • Increase awareness in the public, media, governmental and private sectors about the increasingly serious situation of Physical Education world-wide;
  • Offer a platform for organizations and institutes to present the activities they are undertaking;
  • Identify areas where co-operation is necessary;
  • Compile existing research, statements and declarations;
  • Strengthen networks and co-ordinate plans of action and implementation.

We welcome the opportunity to co-operate with Ministers and Senior Officials and hope that by working together, we can extend the benefits and joys of Physical Education to more children across the world.

Prof. Dr. Gudrun Doll-Tepper
President ICSSPE

The Challenge

 

Despite the overwhelming scientific evidence on the value of physical activity, and the fact that the 1978 UNESCO Charter enshrined Physical Education as a basic human right (see page 14), Physical Education is in a perilous position in all regions of the world. Some national governments have either removed Physical Education from the curriculum, or reduced curriculum time allocation.

“. . . Physical Education is not seen as a priority in the ’90s. It is under severe attack and faces competition for time within the school curriculum. Often Physical Education is being taught by generalist teachers with little or no preparation in Physical Education methods. Additionally, budget cutbacks are having a negative impact on the time and resources required to teach a quality Physical Education programme.”
(Mo Mackendrick, President of the Canadian Association for Health, Physical Education (CAH PER3) 1996)

In order to determine the extent of the problem, a world-wide audit (which included an extensive literature survey) of the state and status of Physical Education in schools was initiated by ICSSPE and funded by the International Olympic Committee. The International Committee on Sports Pedagogy played a leading role in ensuring the survey provided the kind of information needed to address and solve current challenges.

Dr. Ken Hardpan, University of Manchester, presented his audit results to set the scene for the World Summit on Physical Education. The audit results show the critical status of Physical Education around the world, regardless of geography or socio-economic status. Five key issues clearly define the challenge Physical Education is facing:

  • Statutory requirements for Physical Education
  • Subject status of Physical Education
  • Curriculum time allocation
  • Teacher training
  • Resources

Sample quotations (in bold letters) and statistics are included. For a full copy of Dr. Hardpan’s report, please contact the International Council of Sport Science and Physical Education.

Results of World-wide Survey on the State and Status of Physical Education

1. Statutory Requirements for Physical Education

In 92% of the 126 countries sampled, Physical Education is legally required but few countries actually implement their statutory requirements. Globally around 30% of Physical Education is dropped to make way for other subjects.

In a Province of Canada, it is estimated that 97.8% of schools may not meet the allotted Physical Education curriculum time.

In an African country, “It is not enforced. Some teachers do not teach it at all and nobody seems to bother” (Physical Education Professor)

In another African country, it is a compulsory subject, “yet the majority of schools do not present P.E. at all.” (Physical Education professor)

2. Subject Status of Physical Education

In many regions of the world, Physical Education is perceived as being a non-productive educational activity, less important to a successful future than academic subjects. Physical Education occupies a low position at the bottom of the ‘curriculum barrel’. Overall 86% of countries’ respondents indicate that Physical Education has attained a similar legal status to other subjects, but this is not matched in practice.

In an Oceanian country, teachers have expressed concerns that the “image of Physical Education that perseveres with the school’s management and other teaching staff renders it as a marginal subject… not worthy of valuable timetable space.”

In a Latin American country, a Physical Education lecturer indicates that the state attaches little importance to Physical Education and continues to decrease its importance by reducing space for the subject and not providing facilities.

In a European country, the “status of Physical Education … is an essential problem – (its) legal status is revealed by a low division of time for Physical Education confirmed through central school policy (and generally), the actual exercising status is lower than other subjects”.

3. Curriculum Time Allocation

Most curriculum time is allocated when children are between 9-14 years of age, with reductions in time as age increases – especially in the upper years of schooling, when it either becomes an optional subject or it disappears from the timetable.

“Estimated activity levels increase during childhood into early adolescence, and then decline as youth pass through adolescence.” (R. Malina, World Summit on Physical Education 1999)

In one European country more than half a million hours of Physical Education have been lost in primary schools in the year 1998-’99 to make time for literacy and numeracy work.

In another European country, Physical Education time has been reduced from three hours a week to one hour a week during the last decade i.e. from 537 hours to 460 hours in the compulsory school years. “The sports days in school (have also been) canceled…(with) total reduction of movement in school … to about a third.”

In secondary schools in a Latin American country, Physical Education has been reduced from three to one or two classes per week.

4. Teacher Training

Too often Physical Education teachers in primary or elementary schools are untrained for the subject and some conduct Physical Education lessons as supervised play. Physical Education is taught by the classroom teacher who usually has had little or no training in Physical Education. There are more trained Physical Education teachers at the secondary level, but many Physical Education classes are still given by untrained teachers.

“On average post-graduate trainees do 23 hours and undergraduates 32 hours. But some do as little as seven-and-a-half.” (Office for Standards in Education – England and Wales, 1999)

5. Resources

Funding for Physical Education is being disproportionately cut as government departments try and cope with reduced funding. The result is a loss in both the quantity and quality of Physical Education programs. Both the provision of facilities and their maintenance are inadequate in many schools world-wide. Globally, only 31% of countries have adequate facilities. In the less developed countries, there are greater challenges in providing a full range of facilities; but even in countries with more established systems of Physical Education, there were reports of poor maintenance and loss of facilities.

In a European country, “decreased funding has resulted in a reduction in the number of hours for Physical Education within several cantons, even though this contravenes the federally set minimum for the subject.” (Physical Education teacher).

In a state of the USA, in some schools, shared facilities like “all purpose rooms (lunchroom, auditorium, gym) restrict accessibility; some urban schools do not have a gymnasium and have limited outdoor space”;

whilst in another state of the USA, a teacher “… lost gym space over the summer (they turned one of our gyms into a library). We have a large number of students and some classes have to take place in the cafeteria .”

 

Overall, the findings of the survey indicate a widespread scepticism and pessimism for the future of school Physical Education. Physical Education has been pushed into a defensive position. It is suffering from decreasing time in the curriculum, budgetary controls with inadequate financial, material and human resources, and low subject status and esteem. It is being ever more marginalised and undervalued by authorities.

However, despite these problems, there were many examples of good practice across the world. In all cases, such quality Physical Education is led by teachers with good training and skills.

“Physical Education is at great risk of being lost altogether in the next five years due to the diminished and marginalised position the subject has found itself in.” (Doecke, Papua New Guinea 1998)

Request to MINEPS III

At the World Summit on Physical Education (Berlin, November 3-5, 1999), 250 delegates from 80 countries representing governments, inter-governmental and non-governmental organizations and academic institutions from all regions of the world endorsed the Berlin Agenda and its Call for Action by Ministers and Senior Officials responsible for Education and Sport.

The Call for Action asks Officials at MINEPS III to endorse the Berlin Agenda (see Appendix 1) and the Call for Action asks Government leaders to undertake the following:

  • to implement policies for Physical Education as a human right for all children;
  • to recognize that quality Physical Education depends on well-qualified educators and scheduled time within the curriculum. Both these are possible even when other resources like equipment are in short supply;
  • to invest in initial and in-service professional training and development for educators;
  • to support research to improve the effectiveness and quality of Physical Education;
  • to work with international financial institutions to ensure Physical Education is included as part of their definition of education;
  • to recognize the distinctive role of Physical Education in health, overall development and safe, supportive communities;
  • to recognize that failure to provide Physical Education costs more in health care than the investment needed for Physical Education.

Rationale

 

As scientific data from around the world has consistently shown, quality Physical Education can meet a broad range of needs for all people, especially children and youth.

Quality Physical Education:

  • is the most effective and inclusive means of providing all children with the skills, attitudes, values, knowledge and understanding for life long participation in physical activity and sport;
  • helps to ensure integrated and rounded development of mind, body and spirit;
  • is the only school subject whose primary focus is on the body, physical activity, physical development and health;
  • helps children to develop the patterns of and interest in physical activity, which are essential for healthy development and which lay the foundations for adult healthy lifestyles;
  • helps children to develop respect for the body – both their own and others’;
  • develops understanding of the role of physical activity in promoting health;
  • contributes to children’s confidence and self esteem;
  • enhances social development by preparing children to cope with competition, winning and losing; and co-operation and collaboration;
  • provides the skills and knowledge for future work in sport, physical activity, recreation and leisure, a growing area of employment.

Research Findings

At the World Summit on Physical Education 1999, international delegates presented research evidence from around the globe on benefits of Physical Education and its important role in developing healthy, active children. Additional relevant research is also included. The physical domain of Physical Education emphases (1) instruction in motor skills and the opportunity to practice these skills in a supervised setting, (2) development and improvement of physical fitness, and (3) provision of physical activity on a regular basis in the school setting.

Benefits of Physical Education (and sport):

  • enhances self esteem and reduces tendency to risk behaviors;
  • for girls, reduces likelihood of early sexual activity & teenage pregnancy;
  • reduces negative attitudes to school and dropout;
  • is an important pre-vocational subject;
  • improves health, prevents injuries from poor posture, carrying, poor balance;
  • enhances academic performance;
  • provides experience of structured activity with clear targets and outcomes;
  • provides better understanding of abstracts – speed, distance, depth, force, flight, fairness;
  • offers focus and commitment.

(R. Malina, World Summit on Physical Education 1999)

 

Positive Health Evidence

  • An active lifestyle during childhood is a direct benefit to health in later years.
    (S. Blair 1999)
  • Mainly due to modern technological developments (e.g. cars, elevators, computers, television) within almost all cultures, both children and adults have become less physically active. In some cultures, inactivity and the resultant obesity and diseases have reached ‘crisis proportions’.
    (C. Koop 1999)
  • New scientific studies indicate that fitness may contribute more-to a long healthy life than any other factor, including smoking. Moderate regular activity reduces the likelihood of high blood pressure, heart disease, colon cancer and depression.
    (C. Koop 1999)
  • The declining level of exercise has the potential to increase the burden of chronic disease in our population, indirectly through increased obesity and directly as an independent risk factor
    (O. Bar Or 1994)
  • The strength of muscles and bones and the flexibility of joints are important to produce the co-ordinations, balance and ability of movement needed to perform everyday tasks. These components all show a substantial decrease with age and this is partly due to declining levels of physical activity.
    (World Forum on Physical Activity and Sport, Quebec 1995)
  • Besides the role of physical activity on disease prevention, both physical (cardiovascular disease, diabetes, colon cancer, obesity, and osteoporosis) and mental (depression and stress), physical activity, games and sports, can play a significant role in the enrichment of social life and the development of one’s social interaction skills.
    (World Forum on Physical Activity and Sport, Quebec 1995)
  • Activity has been shown to have favorable effects on anxiety, depression, self-esteem and some measures of cognition.
    (S. Biddle 1995)

Evidence for Cognitive Development and Academic Achievement

  • Numerous studies have shown that by adding activity to the children’s curriculum, thereby reducing time in academic subjects no reduction on grades and standardized tests were found and many children were found to improve their grades and academic learning.
    (R. Shephard 1997)
  • Comparing 6-12 year old children who receive 5 hours per week to 40 minutes per week found those with more activity showed significant difference in academic performance.
    (R. Shephard and R. Lavelle 1994)

Economic Evidence

  • “Neglecting Physical Education will prove more costly than providing it….A 25% increase in participation from the initial base of 33% of the population who regularly take part in physical activity would reduce health costs by $778 million in 1995 dollars and stimulate productivity gains by from 1% – 3%, for from $2 to $5 for every dollar invested. The direct costs of stimulating that increased physical activity would only be $191 million.”
    (B. Kidd, World Summit on Physical Education 1999)
  • One year less disease over a lifetime will save (US) $3-5 billion in health care costs in the state of New York alone.
    (R. Feingold 1994)
  • Sport and leisure account for 1.5% of Gross National Product (GNP) in the European Union
    (European Union, 1998)
  • In the United Kingdom there are more jobs in sport and leisure than in the car industry and agriculture, fisheries and food put together.
    (Sports Council, London 1997)

Evidence for Inclusion

Physical Education is especially important for girls and women, special needs, and cultural groups, who are:

  • More dependent on school PE for learning physical skills;
  • See schools as safe and protected – with parental/cultural approval;
  • Less likely to have opportunities in community and in the commercial sector.
  • For these groups especially, PE teachers (especially women) can be powerful role models and PE can lead to adult jobs. The loss of school PE has the greatest effect on these groups.”
    (M Talbot, World Summit on Physical Education 1999)
  • “Increasing Physical Education in schools and in the community will remove one of the major limitations to child health, especially for children from lower socio-economic groups.”
    (V. Matsudo, World Summit on Physical Education 1999)
  • “Quality Physical Education lessons are equitable (gender, culture, race, ability in all aspects.”
    (Global Vision for Physical Education, 1996)

Quality Physical Education

At the World Summit on Physical Education, presenters (M. Talbot, W. Brettschneider, D. Solomons, B. Kidd, inter alia) outlined recommendations on quality Physical Education. This section includes the needs and components of a quality Physical Education experience.

Physical Education needs:

  • Well trained and qualified teachers, both elementary school and high school;
  • Time in the curriculum, for every child and adolescent;
  • Equipment and space;
  • Support for teachers and schools to deliver quality Physical Education;
  • Support for after-school sport and dance.
  • The understanding that Physical Education includes both ‘Learning to Move’ (the skills and understanding required for participation) and ‘Moving to Learn’ (physical activity as a way of learning).

Children and young people, whatever their abilities and despite living in a wide range of countries and cultures, material circumstances, all:

  • Need to develop physically and grow;
  • Are predisposed to be physically active;
  • Need to experience being children before they have to be adult;
  • Learn best through activity;
  • Respond best to enjoyment and achievement.

Effective Physical Education has the following characteristics:

  • Child-Centered: the focus is on the child, not sport. This demonstrates that each child is unique and worth-while and should be treated as such. Activities should be learner-paced and take into consideration the differences among children.
  • Create a Positive Environment: the educator is the motivating force – not only in planning activities, but also in creating a positive teacher-learner atmosphere.
  • Skills and Knowledge Building Toward independence and Independent Learners: in the holistic development of the learner, all learners can learn regardless of competency and skill levels. Physical Education offers each child an opportunity to make choices, develop values and attitudes that support independent learning in a self-disciplined way.
  • Human Rights, gender equity and peace education are important aspects that can the enhanced during the presentation of Physical Education activities.

“Schools reach all young people – girls and boys, the physically strong and the not so strong; the socially privileged and the socially weak – thereby avoiding social inequality and disintegration.”
(D. Solomons, World Summit on Physical Education,1999)

All learners should be provided with a sound knowledge of healthy living and a safe way of living. As education is a life-long process, sound health and human movement practices can contribute to the prevention of health-related problems and can improve the quality of life of learners.

“Physical Education is the place for improving physical fitness and developing motor skills. In addition, in Physical Education classes young people are empowered to assume responsibility for developing an interest in physical activity of their own accord and for adopting an active lifestyle.”
(W. Brettschneider, World Summit on Physical Education 1999)

“(..) Unfortunately, the reality is that not only are the time mandates for Physical Education in public and private schools continually decreasing, but there are many education programmes world-wide whose curriculum does not include Physical Education at all. Further, we should not confuse athletics with physical education because they are not synonymous. […]The purpose and campaign of promoting physical activity through developmentally appropriate Physical Education has never been more compelling. We desperately need to develop an international commitment to ensure that all children receive the encouragement, training and support they need to develop and maintain active, healthy lifestyles…),”
(M. Murray, 1999)

“… We cannot meet our obligations to make the world a better place for our children without contributing significantly to their physically active health and enrichment. We should hold our leaders to that promise.”
(B. Kidd, World Summit on Physical Education 1999)
Supporting Statements

This section is designed to provide resources for Ministers and Senior Officials to build the case for Physical Education at a local, regional or national level. It includes several examples of international policy statements.

  • UNESCO – The International Charter of Physical Education and Sport
  • “… one of the essential conditions for the effective exercise of human rights is that everyone should be free to develop and preserve his or her physical, intellectual and moral powers, and that access to Physical Education and sport should consequently be assured and guaranteed for all human beings.”

“Article 1:
The practice of Physical Education and sport is a fundamental right for all .
Article 2:
Physical Education and sport form an essential element of lifelong education in the overall education system.
Article 3:
Physical Education and sport programmes must meet individual and social need.
Article 4:
Teaching, coaching and administration of Physical Education and sport programmes must meet individual and social needs.
Article 5:
Adequate facilities and equipment are essential to Physical Education and sport.
Article 6:
Research and evaluation are indispensable components of the development of Physical Education and sport.
Article 7:
Protection of the ethnical and moral values of Physical Education and sport must be a constant concern for all.
Article 8:
Information and documentation help to promote Physical Education and sport.
Article 9:
The mass media should exert a positive influence on Physical Education and sport.
Article 10:
National institutions play a major role in Physical Education and sport.
Article 11:
International co-operation is a prerequisite for the universal and well-balanced promotion of Physical Education.”

  • World Forum on Physical Activity and Sport, Quebec 1995
    Encouraging children in adolescence to engage in physical activity helps them to establish good health habits and avoid smoking or drug abuse. The enhancement of self-image and relief of boredom produced by physical activity may also enhance classroom performance.
  • World Health Organization
    The goals of Physical Education in schools are: 1) lay the foundations for life-long active living; 2) develop and enhance the health and well-being of the students; 3) to offer enjoyment, fun and social interaction; and 4) to help to prevent/reduce future health problems. Currently, most schools in most countries around the world cannot meet these goals because the time in the curriculum and the resources for teaching of quality Physical Education are inadequate.
  • The basic reason is the ignorance of the importance of physical activity for young people. This’ in turn, is largely due to the fact that policy and decision makers, teachers, other professionals, parents and various other concerned groups, have no adequate knowledge of the need for physical activity and its benefits for the present and future health and well-being of young people.
  • Schools can and should 1) allow each child and young person to take part in a structured Physical Education curriculum and in physical activity sessions of moderate to vigorous levels regularly, several times each week, and 2) offer a range of physical activities outside the school system, i.e. in the community with the support of parents, peers, community leaders and local sport and social organizations.
  • Appropriate professional development and training opportunities should be provided for all those involved in organizing physical activities in and through schools, including teachers, local leaders, coaches, and recreation and health care personnel. The aim is to increase their capacity in programme planing and in educating, motivating, guiding and building the confidence of young people.
  • “An ‘active school’ is a healthier and better-performing school and a better place to work.”
    Promoting Active Living in and through Schools – A World Health Organization Statement 1998
  • Global Vision for Physical Education 1996 (Statement by CAHPERD and AAPHERD)

All students in every grade should have the right and opportunity to experience sustained, vigorous physical activity, and participate in quality, daily Physical Education programmes.

  • Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting – Committee on Co-operation Through Sport

Physical Education:

    • should be required component on all teacher training courses
    • should be priority subject for training
    • should be essential in curriculum
    • should attract grants for equipment
      (Endorsed by Commonwealth Education Ministers 1995)
  • 3rd International Olympic Forum for Development 1998, Malaysia
    The 3rd International Olympic Forum for Development “..reinforces the need to build the case for investment in sport and Physical Education both nationally and internationally especially by critical analysis of sport’s role as a tool for development.”
  • All Africa Pre-Games Scientific Congress, September 1999
    With the endorsement of the Supreme Council for Sport in Africa (SCSA) and supported and endorsed by delegates, the following was accepted:
  • Action Plan – Prefatory Statement
    “Physical Education should be recognized as the basis of the physical activity participation continuum. School Physical Education should be seen as the most important aspect for the development of sport. If traditions of physical activity are developed in schools, children are more likely to participate in out-of-school and post-school settings.”
  • The participants “…urge all governments, inter- and non-governmental organizations involved in education and relevant associated areas to take corrective action to reverse the declining trend and to promote Physical Education.”
  • 3rd International Conference for Women and Sport (Association for Arab Women and Sport), October 1999The following Declaration was accepted by the participants:”The Physical Education of Arab girls suffers from negative attitudes towards girls’ benefitting from school Physical Education, which is a part of her life and future. In the light of the inadequacy of the human and material resources and expertise needed for practicing sport activities, and the low care shown by those responsible for girls’ Physical Education, this conference makes the following declaration: Raise standards of school Physical Education for Arab girls.”
  • National Children’s Agenda, Canada, 1999
    “…as a nation, we aspire to have children who are healthy – both emotionally and physically, safe and secure, successful at learning, and socially engaged and responsible.”

Conclusion

 

The world-wide survey on the state of Physical Education, and other international research provides an enormous challenge to address the status and resources for Physical Education. Most government Departments are working hard trying to balance the overwhelming number of requests for their limited resources However, when Physical Education is not incorporated as an integral part of education programmes, the consequences can be long-lasting and manifold.

Physical Education can provide a large number of health, social, cognitive and economic benefits. Physical Education can and does provide a Return on Investment (R013 in other areas of spending, most notably health. Based on the evidence presented in this paper, we ask the participants of the Third International Conference of Ministers and Senior Officials Responsible for Sport and Physical Activities (MINEPS III) to endorse the Berlin Agenda for Action and to implement the recommendations at the national, and local levels.

Working together we can make a difference for our most precious resource — today’s children and youth.

This is an international problem requiring international, regional and national action

Annex 1

The Berlin Agenda for Action for Government Ministers

The World Summit on Physical Education reinforces the importance of Physical Education as a
life-long process. It is particularly important for every child as articulated in the International Convention on the Rights of the Child. All children have a right to (1) the highest level of health; (2) free and compulsory primary education for both cognitive and physical development; (3) rest and leisure; play and recreation.

THE BERLIN AGENDA CALLS FOR ACTION BY GOVERNMENTS AND MINISERIES RESPONSIBLE FOR EDUCATION AND SPORT TO:

  • implement policies for Physical Education as a human right for all children;
  • recognize that quality Physical Education depends on well-qualified educators and scheduled time within the curriculum, both of which are possible to provide even when other resources like equipment are in short supply;
  • invest in initial and in-service professional training and development for educators;
  • support research to improve the effectiveness and quality of Physical Education;
  • work with international financial institutions to ensure Physical Education is included as part of their of definition of education;
  • recognize the distinctive role of Physical Education in health, overall development and safe, supportive communities;
  • recognize that failure to provide Physical Education costs more in health care than the investment needed for Physical Education.

Why take these actions? Quality Physical Education:

  • is the most effective and inclusive means of providing all children, whatever their ability/disability, sex, age, cultural, race/ethnicity, religious or social background, with the skills, attitudes, values, knowledge and understanding for life long participation in physical activity and sport;
  • helps to ensure integrated and rounded development of mind, body and spirit;
  • is the only school subject whose primary focus is on the body, physical activity, physical development and health;
  • helps children to develop the patterns of and interest in physical activity, which are essential for healthy development and which lay the foundations for adult healthy lifestyles;
  • helps children to develop respect for the body – both their own and others’;
  • develops understanding of the role of physical activity in promoting health;
  • contributes to children’s confidence and self esteem;
  • enhances social development by preparing children to cope with competition, winning an losing; and co-operation and collaboration;
  • provides the skills and knowledge for future work in sport, physical activity, recreation and leisure, a growing area of employment.

BERLIN, November 5, 1999


Annex 2

Appeal of the World Summit on Physical Education to the General Conference of UNESCO

The representatives of states, intergovernmental and non-governmental organizations, and educational institutions at the World Summit on Physical Education, held in BERLIN from November 3-5, 1999.

Considering the importance of Physical Education for every child around the world, and its role in encouraging people to remain active and healthy throughout their life-span,

Considering that Physical Education helps to ensure integrated and rounded development of mind, body and spirit and contributes to children’s confidence and self-esteem,

Emphasizing that Physical Education can enhance cognitive, academic achievement and social development including fundamental educational skills like literacy, and numeracy.

Noting that Physical Education is the most effective and inclusive means of providing children, whatever their ability, age, sex, cultural or religious background, with the skills, knowledge and understanding for lifelong participation in physical activity and sport,

Reaffirming that Physical Education provides skills and knowledge for employment in sport, physical activity, public health, recreation and leisure, a growing area of vocational opportunity,

Reaffirming that Physical Education provides an ethical and social foundation for the spirit of fair play, mutual respect, solidarity and human understanding.

  1. Call upon the General Conference to record the urgent need to promote Physical Education and the resources required for delivering quality programmes in Physical Education to be made available.
  2. Urge the Ministers of Education and the Ministers of Youth and Sport: to recognize the distinctive role that Physical Education and sport play in the education of young people and that Physical Education and sport are a human right for all children; to mandate adequate e time in the school curriculum; and to support research to improve the effectiveness and quality of Physical Education programmes.
  3. Urge the General Conference to commit to developing strategies for effective implementation of Physical Education programmes in the education system and the community, with the necessary financial and human resources.
  4. Request the General Conference to encourage the allocation of adequate human and financial resources through the inter-governmental Committee for Physical Education and Sport of UNESCO (CIGEPS!)
  5. Urge the General Conference to invite the Director General of UNESCO to mobilize intergovernmental and non-governmental organizations, public and private sectors to cooperate in the promotion and development of Physical Education within the context of a culture of peace.
  6. Request the General Conference to invite the Director General of UNESCO to submit the Appeal from the World Summit on Physical Education to the Third International Conference of Ministers and Senior Officials of Physical Education and Sport to be held in Punta del Este from November 30-December 3, 1999.

Annex 3

Scientific Programme of the World Summit on Physical Education

Programme highlights / Keynotes

  • World Wide Audit Survey of the State and Status of Physical Education in Schools Dr. Ker’ Hardman, Past-President of the International/ Society for Comparative Physical Education and Sport, University of Manchester, UK
  • The Case for Physical Education Prof. Dr. Margaret Talbot, President of the International Association of Physical Education and Sport for Girls and Women, Leeds Metropolitan University, UK
  • Good Practices in Physical Education Doreen Solomons, Western Cape Education Department, South Africa
  • Nutritional Needs for Physical Activity in Young People Prof. Dr. Clyde Williams, Loughborough University, UK
  • Physical Education and its Physical Domains Prof. Dr. Robert Malina, Michigan State University, USA
  • Psychological Outcomes and Social Benefits of Sport Involvement and Physical Activity Implications for Physical Education Prof. Dr. Wolf-Dietrich Brettschneider, university Gesamthochschule Paderborn, Germany
  • Physical Education, Health and Well-Being Prof. Dr. Victor Matsudo, CELA FISCS, Brazil
  • The Economic Case for Physical Education Prof. Dr. Bruce Kidd, University of Toronto, Canada

Workshops

  • Physical Education in National Development and Reconstruction
    Marcia Oxley, Director, Commonwealth Sports Development Programme, Barbados / Doreen Solomons, Western Cape Education Department, South ,Africa
  • Managing Diversity- Inclusion and Integration
    Prof. Dr. Karen DePauw, Past-President of the Intemational Federation of Adapted Physical Activity, Washington State University, USA I J. Wilton Littlechild, WlNsport, Canada
  • Working Towards a Balanced Curriculum
    Dr. Richard J. Fisher, President of the European Union of Physical Education Associations, St. Mary’s College, Twickenham, VK / Dr. Irina Ugolkova, Russian State Academy for Physical Education
  • Making the Economic Case
    Prof. Dr. Bruce Kidd, University of Toronto, Canada / Marce/lin Dally, Physical Education and Sport Unit, UNESCO
  • Advocacy and Lobbying Strategies Prof. Dr. Ronald Feingold, President of the Association
    Internationale des Ecoles Superieures d’Education Physique, President AAHPERD, Ade/phi University – Garden City, USA I Hamadi Benaziza, Department of Health Promotion – Focal Point on Active Living, WHO
  • Physical Education for Health: Active Schools
    Prof. Dr. Ilika Vuori, Director of the UKK Institute, Tampere, Finland I Prof. Dr. Frank Fu, Hong Kong Baptist University, Hong Kong of China
  • Physical Education, Schools and Community
    Dr. Gerhard Trosien, German Sports Confederation, Frankfurt’ Germany / Christine Spain, President’s Council on Fitness and Sport, Washington, USA

 

2013-11-27T16:48:05-06:00February 13th, 2008|Contemporary Sports Issues, Sports Facilities, Sports Management, Sports Studies and Sports Psychology|Comments Off on Results and Recommendations of the World Summit on Physical Education
Go to Top